Before the Dawn (2019) is, without exaggeration, the worst film I’ve ever seen—and for one giant reason: it’s pedophile apologia.
Yes, the script is laughably bad, the performances are wood stiff, and the whole thing reeks of self-importance. But what really makes it irredeemable is how brazenly it romanticizes statutory rape.
Look at the poster. The framing is a giant red flag: a classroom, a chalkboard, students in their desks—then front and center, a teacher in a low-cut red top pressing forehead-to-forehead with a teenage boy. The film isn’t hiding its subject matter. It’s flaunting it.
And in case you think this is going to be a hard look at a predatory teacher? Nope. The movie bills itself as romance. A tale of “forbidden love.” Complete with sex scenes between a grown adult woman and a student the script explicitly identifies as a child. His own mother calls him that on screen. She’s the lone character sounding alarms, yet even she never calls the cops.
What’s worse is how the movie spins the teacher. She’s not written as a manipulative abuser—she’s painted as a tragic victim of fate, a woman who “just can’t deny her feelings.” But everything she does is textbook predator behavior. She initiates the flirtation. She arranges secret after-school sessions. She isolates him from peers. That’s not chemistry. That’s grooming.
Then comes one of the most revolting narrative choices: she’s raped by another teacher, a jealous colleague. But instead of being treated with the horror it deserves, the assault is basically used to reposition her as the damsel so her student can rush in as a white knight. She’s still framed as sympathetic, while the student’s abuse is reframed as noble love.
And here’s the kicker: lead actress Alana de Freitas didn’t just star as the teacher. She wrote the screenplay. Which makes the whole thing reads like wish fulfillment. The teacher is styled as an almost flawless archetype, her only “sin” being that she “follows her heart.”
The reception is equally nauseating. It sits at 5.8 on IMDb—above average. Read the reviews and you’ll see people praising it as “taboo romance” or “forbidden fruit.” Some even root for the characters to stay together.
Festivals went further. LA Femme International Film Festival nominated it for Best Feature Film. Boston International and Focus International both did likewise. Why on earth are professional festivals handing trophies to what amounts to pedophile propaganda?
Let’s be honest. If the genders were reversed, there would have been outrage. The movie would’ve been buried. Instead, Before the Dawn got distribution through Indie Rights, found its way onto Apple TV, Roku, and Pluto TV, and even snagged a write-up in American Cinematographer—where the DP proudly talks about building rain rigs out of Hudson sprayers and bouncing light off a king-sized bedsheet. Microbudget quirks shouldn’t eclipse the fact that what they were lighting was a sex scene between a teacher and her student.
This gets to the bigger problem: society’s double standard when it comes to female sexual predators. When the abuser is an attractive blonde, too many people celebrate it. “Boys should be grateful,” they say. Grateful that someone with authority over them coerces them into sex? Call it what it is: rape.
And this isn’t some obscure edge case. Google “female teacher charged with sexual assault” and you’ll see fresh arrests almost every week. Women abusing boys. Women abusing girls. These are predators with direct access to children, and somehow movies like Before the Dawn end up celebrating them.
Some defenders try to split hairs, calling this ephebophilia instead of pedophilia. But ephebophilia isn’t even a recognized clinical diagnosis. The law is crystal clear: anyone under the age of consent is a child. Which makes this predatory behavior. Full stop.
Normally, I’d link to streaming platforms so you can judge a film for yourself. Not this time. Before the Dawn disgusts me too much. It’s out there on major corporate platforms, which in itself is damning—they’ll happily profit off a film that romanticizes teacher-student rape, as long as the predator is a pretty woman.
Ehhh I definitely see 5th Element as being fairly fucking creepy… Leloo (sp?)'s … whole thing is that she basically has an insane case of coma induced amnesia, and in many ways is… mentally, a child, for much of the film.
So… yeah, its kind of the inverse of the 383 year old witch girl that just happens to be in a 14 yo’s body trope thing.
This is an … on the threshold of adulthood/legally consentable person’s body… that is inhabited by someone who is extremely scared, confused, traumatized, has no idea wtf is going on, doesn’t even intially speak the language of those around her… due to… ostensibly being a person who has been… either dead and then regrown, or in a coma for … thousands of years… or something like that… by the logic of the movie.
(I am just now realizing that the 5th Element is an Isekai from Leloo’s pov)
I know the whole core of the movie at the end is love, but its still fucking weird, frankly regardless of the physical age gap, to be sexualizing someone who is not of a normal adult’s mental capacity.
…
Now, Leon?
NatPort’s character, uh, Mathilda, … very much does develop a uh… uncomfortable level of attraction to Leon.
But as best as I remember… Leon is basically terrified of and disgusted by this, acting much more like a protective and nurturing surrogate father than a uh … ‘daddy’.
He consistently refuses her more uh, risque behaviors and advances.
She, on the other hand, is a traumatized orphan from a family that is … fairly strongly implied to have exposed her to a lot of sexualized behaviors … before they were all killed, in front of her…
I think that Mathilda acting the way she does toward Leon is psychologically plausible, though it is uncomfortable to actually see… but what we see from Leon is… arguably, a pretty responsible and non exploitative way of handling this… given the somewhat insane overall scenario/premise of the movie.
…
Frankly, having grown up in a white trash neighborhood… I actually knew girls, my age, growing up, who acted a lot like Mathilda, barely into middle school and constantly making highly explicit sexual references… and offers… at the bus stop…
And without going into too much detail, the father in that family ended up going to prison…for repeatedly SA’ing his older daughter… that whole situation had been going on in secret for years…
… and it finally blew up when he tried to start doing this to his younger daughter as well, and the older daughter and mother ended up getting into a brawl with the father.
Yeah. Not… great, very not good.
But, sadly, a quite young girl acting highly sexually provocative… yeah, that does happen… when that kind of behavior has been traumatically normalized for them.
For what its worth, last time I talked to that girl, a woman by that time, she had found a partner her age, they had been together for some years she was very much in love, they were planning to marry, and moved faaaaar away, so I hope things worked out for them, they seemed like they could.
To the best of my knowledge the dad is uh, still in prison, probably gonna be there for quite a while longer.