• 108 Posts
  • 786 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: February 19th, 2024

help-circle

















  • Here’s how I might resolve this supposed dichotomy:

    • “AI” doesn’t actually exist.
      • You might be using technologies that are called “AI” but there is no actual “intelligence” there. For example, as OP mentions, LLMs are extremely limited and not actually “intelligent”.
    • Since “AI” doesn’t actually exist, since there’s no objective test, etc… “AI” can be anything and do anything.
    • So at the extremes we get the “AI” God and “AI” Devil
      • “AI” God - S/he saves the economy, liberates us from drudgery, creates great art, saves us from China (\s), heralds the singularity, etc.
      • “AI” Devil - S/he hallucinates, steals jobs, destroys the environment, is a tool of the MIC, murders artists, is how China will destroy us (\s), wastes of time and resources, is a scam, causes apocalypses, etc.

    Since there’s no objective meaning from the start, there’s no coherence or reason behind the wild conclusions are the bottom. When we talk about “AI”, we’re talking about a wide variety of technologies with varying values in various contexts. I think there are some real shitty people/products but also some hopefully useful technologies. So depending on the situation I might have a different opinion.