I sincerely hope that’s a sarcastic question. If I’m taking the bait, I’ll wear the dunce cap: The litnus test for whether an ideology should exist at all is whether or not it requires the extinction of all other ideologies. If a system accepts multiple viewpoints and inputs, literally that it’s DEI, it is a good system. If a system exists that recognizes an ideology within itself is calling for the extermination of all others and snuffs it out, it is a great system. See Nazis.
Edit: Because you .ml types stretch every phrase, “see nazis” means see what happened to them, where other ideologies banded together against them.
If communism/1-state solutions require all other forms of belief to be expunged, it should be expunged itself.
A country as diverse as the USA? I’m all for diversity, but the US is a monolinguistic monocultural state. No other language than English, no other culture than Christian… Those are the roots of the USA. Hell, even some small countries like Spain or Belgium have multiple official languages.
That’s just straight up untrue. Latin culture and language is very much alive within our nation, as are African, European, and Asian cultures. We are witnessing the dying gasp of the white Christian roots myth. The true America beneath that facade are the everyday people in the margins that make up this immigrant nation, and this rise of fascism and neoliberalism is exactly the sign that the idea of a white Christian nation is coming undone.
Look what they have to do to maintain the myth. Look how hard they grasp for anything to make their own foundational lies seem real. Look how you’re buying that lie.
I’m not saying there’s no potential, but come on, for the size of the US it’s incredibly homogeneous. Compare that to, say, China, which has many different provinces with different majority ethnicities, same in Russia, same in India regarding languages… The US is definitely a very non-diverse place for its size, as a byproduct of its short history and the policy over the past 200 years.
We must live in very different Americas. It looks a lot more different when you’re out there with the people. Every region is different. Cultures, goals, a hodgepodge of immigrant customs and a beautiful mosaic of faces. Even in my sleepy midwest city there’s so much more than white Christian culture that has stood in stark contrast to the narrative that we are solely an anglican-aryan nation.
I grew up a military brat. I’ve seen nearly every corner of this country. I’ve seen with my own eyes what the melting pot actually looks like beyond my own social media bubble. A nation is more than it’s incumbency. People live here.
Again, I’m comparing to other nations. Go to China, for example. Go to Canton, then go to Xinjiang, and finally to Beijing. Three entirely different cultural areas, with different majority languages. You simply cannot find anything remotely close in the USA. Now do the same in Russia, and move from Moscow to Tatarstan, then Ulan-Ude and then to Chechnya. Again, the US is very homogeneous for a country with its span and population.
West coast, new england, bible belt, bayou/french south, texas, the midwest, the latin basin. These are vastly different cultural regions. Your argument isn’t holding water to me. I’ve lived in many different places, and you just can’t have a landmass as big as the US or China and make it homogenous. It just doesn’t happen. People don’t work that way.
Just because the government has only 1 “official” language doesn’t mean other cultures don’t exist within the country. In my area businesses post signs in English, Spanish, Korean, Cantonese (pretty sure it’s not Mandarin, but I’m not an expert), and occasionally Vietnamese, Thai or Hindi.
And like… have you ever walked around NYC? nothing further from a monoculture.
Plus you’ve pretty much just dismissed all the Native American tribes that still speak their own languages.
Only true if you want to form a monoculture, which is a seriously bad goal in a country as diverse and broad as the US.
But how can my ideology win, if other ideologies exist?
I sincerely hope that’s a sarcastic question. If I’m taking the bait, I’ll wear the dunce cap: The litnus test for whether an ideology should exist at all is whether or not it requires the extinction of all other ideologies. If a system accepts multiple viewpoints and inputs, literally that it’s DEI, it is a good system. If a system exists that recognizes an ideology within itself is calling for the extermination of all others and snuffs it out, it is a great system. See Nazis.
Edit: Because you .ml types stretch every phrase, “see nazis” means see what happened to them, where other ideologies banded together against them.
If communism/1-state solutions require all other forms of belief to be expunged, it should be expunged itself.
what do you mean, “you people”?
A country as diverse as the USA? I’m all for diversity, but the US is a monolinguistic monocultural state. No other language than English, no other culture than Christian… Those are the roots of the USA. Hell, even some small countries like Spain or Belgium have multiple official languages.
That’s just straight up untrue. Latin culture and language is very much alive within our nation, as are African, European, and Asian cultures. We are witnessing the dying gasp of the white Christian roots myth. The true America beneath that facade are the everyday people in the margins that make up this immigrant nation, and this rise of fascism and neoliberalism is exactly the sign that the idea of a white Christian nation is coming undone.
Look what they have to do to maintain the myth. Look how hard they grasp for anything to make their own foundational lies seem real. Look how you’re buying that lie.
I’m not saying there’s no potential, but come on, for the size of the US it’s incredibly homogeneous. Compare that to, say, China, which has many different provinces with different majority ethnicities, same in Russia, same in India regarding languages… The US is definitely a very non-diverse place for its size, as a byproduct of its short history and the policy over the past 200 years.
We must live in very different Americas. It looks a lot more different when you’re out there with the people. Every region is different. Cultures, goals, a hodgepodge of immigrant customs and a beautiful mosaic of faces. Even in my sleepy midwest city there’s so much more than white Christian culture that has stood in stark contrast to the narrative that we are solely an anglican-aryan nation.
I grew up a military brat. I’ve seen nearly every corner of this country. I’ve seen with my own eyes what the melting pot actually looks like beyond my own social media bubble. A nation is more than it’s incumbency. People live here.
Again, I’m comparing to other nations. Go to China, for example. Go to Canton, then go to Xinjiang, and finally to Beijing. Three entirely different cultural areas, with different majority languages. You simply cannot find anything remotely close in the USA. Now do the same in Russia, and move from Moscow to Tatarstan, then Ulan-Ude and then to Chechnya. Again, the US is very homogeneous for a country with its span and population.
West coast, new england, bible belt, bayou/french south, texas, the midwest, the latin basin. These are vastly different cultural regions. Your argument isn’t holding water to me. I’ve lived in many different places, and you just can’t have a landmass as big as the US or China and make it homogenous. It just doesn’t happen. People don’t work that way.
oh yeah, definitely all the same language:
Just because the government has only 1 “official” language doesn’t mean other cultures don’t exist within the country. In my area businesses post signs in English, Spanish, Korean, Cantonese (pretty sure it’s not Mandarin, but I’m not an expert), and occasionally Vietnamese, Thai or Hindi.
And like… have you ever walked around NYC? nothing further from a monoculture.
Plus you’ve pretty much just dismissed all the Native American tribes that still speak their own languages.